THE SHORT ANSWER

Both remove a lot. CDC says distillation removes germs and many chemicals (including lead, arsenic, nitrate and sodium), but not some volatile organic compounds, volatile solvents and certain pesticides, and it generally uses more energy and takes longer. Reverse osmosis removes germs and some chemicals, and may reduce others such as arsenic, fluoride, radium and nitrate (CDC). If you want drinking water on tap at the kitchen sink, an under-sink RO unit delivers it through its own faucet; a distiller collects batches in a container. EPA notes distillation is energy-intensive while RO sends water down the drain (EPA WaterSense guide).

FAQ (quick)

  • Is RO water the same as distilled water? No. They're made differently and remove different things, though both remove a lot of dissolved minerals.
  • Which removes more? It depends on the contaminant. Check the certified claims for the exact unit.
  • Which uses more water? RO. A typical RO unit sends 5 or more gallons down the drain per gallon treated; WaterSense-labeled models send 2.3 or less (EPA).
  • Which uses more energy? Distillation. EPA calls it energy-intensive.
  • Which certification should I look for? NSF/ANSI 58 for RO; NSF/ANSI 62 for distillation (EPA).

How each one works

Distillation boils water and collects it as it cools; most chemical contaminants stay behind in the liquid, and the vapor condenses into a separate container (CDC; EPA guide).

Reverse osmosis uses pressure to push water through a semi-permeable membrane, making a stream of treated water ("permeate") and a stream of reject water ("concentrate") that goes to the drain (EPA WaterSense). CDC puts the membrane's pore size at about 0.0001 micron and notes the water may also pass through filters before and after the membrane.

Side-by-side

DistillationReverse osmosis
Germs (CDC)Removes parasites, bacteria, virusesRemoves parasites, bacteria, viruses
Chemicals CDC says it removesArsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, lead, nitrate, sodium, sulfate, calcium, magnesium and many organic chemicalsSome chemicals, including lead, copper, chromium, chloride and sodium
Chemicals CDC says it may reduce—Arsenic, fluoride, radium, sulfate, calcium, magnesium, potassium, nitrate, phosphorus
What it may miss (CDC/EPA)Some volatile organic compounds, volatile solvents and certain pesticidesDoesn't remove all inorganic and organic contaminants
Water use (EPA)Minimal, for cleaning and maintenanceTypical unit: 5+ gallons to drain per gallon treated; up to 10 for inefficient units; WaterSense labeled: 2.3 or less
Energy (EPA/CDC)Energy-intensive; generally slowerUses pressure to push water through the membrane
Upkeep watch-outBacteria may grow on cooling coils when the unit sits unused (CDC)Filters and membrane need replacing; unmaintained systems can make water worse (EPA)
Certification (EPA)NSF/ANSI 62NSF/ANSI 58
Typical setupCountertop batch unitUnder-sink unit with its own faucet

Sources for the table: CDC; EPA WaterSense guide; EPA WaterSense RO page.

Both also remove minerals. EPA lists "removes beneficial minerals such as calcium" as an RO limitation, and lists hardness among what distillation removes.

What they cost (EPA's general ranges)

EPA's WaterSense guide says basic pitchers and tap filters typically cost less than $100, while distillation and RO systems tend to cost a few hundred dollars and may need professional installation; point-of-entry (whole-house) systems can cost thousands (EPA guide). Those are national ranges, not quotes. Ongoing costs differ too: RO raises water use, and distillation can raise your energy bill (EPA). For RO pricing factors in our area, see reverse osmosis installation cost in Southwest Florida.

Which fits which job

  • Daily drinking and cooking water at the kitchen sink: under-sink RO serves water from its own faucet, so there's no batch to wait for. Choose a WaterSense-labeled, NSF/ANSI 58-certified model to cut water waste. See under-sink reverse osmosis and tank vs. tankless RO.
  • A known volatile organic compound in a well: CDC says distillation may miss some VOCs, so pick a system whose certification covers that exact chemical. EPA lists removal of organic contaminants among carbon filtration's benefits, and some carbon filters can remove cleaning solvents and pesticides. Start with a lab test: private well lab sample planning.
  • Boil water notices: EPA notes a distiller can be used during boil water advisories. With RO, follow your utility's notice and the system's instructions. See boil water notice and home filters.
  • Renters or small spaces: a countertop unit (distiller or countertop RO) avoids under-sink plumbing. See countertop vs. under-sink RO.
  • Whole-house problems (chloramine taste, sulfur smell, hardness): neither one. Those are jobs for whole-home carbon, sulfur treatment or a softener. See whole-home carbon filtration.

Local note for North Port

North Port Utilities treats well water at the Reverse Osmosis facility at its Myakkahatchee Creek plant, and its Southwest Water Treatment Plant in Wellen Park also features reverse osmosis (City of North Port). That's a different job from a kitchen RO unit. Here's how the two fit together: North Port city reverse osmosis. Local pages: drinking water in North Port and RO system installation in North Port.

FAQ

Is distilled water better than RO water? Neither is better across the board. Distillation removes many chemicals but may miss some VOCs and uses more energy; RO removes many contaminants and wastes some water. Match the system to your test results and check its certified claims.

Can I use RO water in a CPAP or steam iron instead of distilled? Follow the device maker's instructions. We didn't find an official source comparing the two for appliances.

Does RO remove fluoride? Does distillation? CDC says RO may reduce fluoride. CDC's distillation list doesn't mention fluoride, so check any distiller's certified claims. More: fluoride reduction claims.

Why does RO waste water? EPA explains that the membrane traps and rejects contaminants, which creates a stream of reject water. EPA says WaterSense-labeled systems send 2.3 gallons or less to the drain per gallon treated. See RO efficiency and waste water.

Do you sell distillers? We install under-sink RO and other plumbed systems. If a distiller fits your needs better, we'll say so.

Next step

Schedule an in-home water check. It isn't a certified lab test; we use it to match a drinking-water system to your utility report or lab results. Or call 941-294-5767. More: Water refill stations vs. under-sink RO

Sources

Drafted 2026-11-12 (America/New_York); sources fetched the same day. Last fact-checked: 2026-11-12 (America/New_York).

PLANNING A NORTH PORT INSTALLATION?

Turn your questions into a clear scope.

Review the home details, equipment questions and ongoing care to discuss before booking. Address coverage and scheduling are confirmed during your callback.

View the North Port installation guide
This guide is educational. Specific treatment recommendations require appropriate water information and an assessment of your home.

A PRACTICAL NEXT STEP

Drinking water, explained.

Fresh-tasting water for every glass, pot of coffee, and family recipe.

Explore this solution