THE SHORT ANSWER
Compare the specific models against cabinet space, water demand and maintenance preferences. Tankless is a layout choice, not proof of better water.
Understand the basic difference
EPA describes tank systems as storing treated water for use, while tankless models treat it as the tap is used and generally take less space. Either design still needs a model-specific comparison of capabilities.
Reference: EPA tank and tankless product guidance
Describe how you fill containers
Do you fill one glass, several bottles at once, or a large cooking pot? Ask how the proposed system performs for that use pattern under the conditions at your home. A daily production figure and the flow you experience at the faucet are not interchangeable questions. Ask the installer to explain both.
Look beyond the footprint
Check the space required to replace filters, not just the dimensions of the housing. Confirm any power requirement, line routing, faucet connection and drain arrangement. If connecting a refrigerator, have the appliance requirements reviewed as part of the design. Neither design should be promised as universally compatible.
Choose an ownership arrangement
Compare cartridge availability, membrane cost, maintenance instructions, service access and warranty terms in writing. Ask what happens if the selected model is discontinued. For a seasonal home, obtain its specific idle and restart instructions. The better choice is the model that fits your household and can be maintained reliably, rather than whichever label sounds newer.
A PRACTICAL NEXT STEP
Drinking water, explained.
Fresh-tasting water for every glass, pot of coffee, and family recipe.
Explore this solution