THE SHORT ANSWER
If the rotten-egg smell comes from both the hot and cold taps, but only from water that has passed through your softener, the Florida Department of Health says the likely cause is sulfur bacteria in the water softener. If untreated water smells too, the problem is upstream: in the well, the plumbing or the groundwater. If only the hot tap smells, look at the water heater. The fix depends on which one it is, so run the tap check below before you change any equipment.
Start here
Step 1: Find an unsoftened tap
A softener usually treats the water for the house. Many homes also have a tap it doesn't feed, such as an outdoor spigot or a dedicated line. If you're not sure which taps bypass your softener, check your installation paperwork or ask your installer. Don't guess from the pipe color.
Step 2: Do the four-way smell check
Fill a clean glass from each tap and smell it right away:
Softened cold
Softened hot
Unsoftened cold
Unsoftened hot, if you have one
Then compare your results with the Florida DOH guidance (PDF):
Hot taps only — The water heater — Sulfur odor: hot or cold water?
Hot and cold, softened water only — Sulfur bacteria in the softener — Steps 3 and 4 below
Strong when first turned on, fades with running, or comes and goes — Sulfur bacteria in the well or plumbing — Sulfur water treatment
Strong and steady on every tap, including untreated — Hydrogen sulfide in the groundwater — Well water solutions
DOH notes that people can smell hydrogen sulfide at very low levels, and that the smell is often stronger at the hot tap because heat helps the gas escape.
Step 3: If it's the softener, start with the basics
These are maintenance checks, not repairs:
Find the owner's manual or the model number on the control valve. The manufacturer's sanitizing instructions come first. Don't improvise chemical doses in a resin tank.
Look in the brine tank. Salt bridges, mushy salt or standing water can mean the softener isn't regenerating properly. See Water softener salt bridge and Softener salt use changed.
Check the clock and settings, especially after a storm or power outage. See Softener after a power interruption.
Think about how much it's been used. A seasonal home or a softener that sat unused can be a reason to call for service. See Seasonal home water system handover.
If the smell comes back after the softener is cleaned, ask a technician to look at the whole system. Something upstream may be feeding the bacteria.
Step 4: Know when it isn't really a softener problem
A softener is built to reduce hardness. It's not a sulfur treatment system. If the four-way check shows the smell in untreated water too, Florida DOH lists these treatment approaches for odor (PDF):
Aeration: air carries the odor compounds out and vents them outside.
Oxidation: an oxidant, or air added through a Venturi nozzle, breaks the odor compounds down.
Adsorption: activated carbon captures the odor compounds.
The right stage, and where it sits relative to the softener, depends on your test results. See Sulfur water treatment in North Port and Carbon filter vs. water softener.
Is the smell a health risk?
Florida DOH says sulfur bacteria aren't harmful, and in most cases the rotten-egg smell isn't related to how clean a well is. It still recommends testing private wells regularly for total coliform bacteria or E. coli, at least once a year and whenever the taste, odor or color changes (PDF). See North Port water testing.
On city water?
The DOH fact sheet is written for private wells. If you're on city water and smell rotten eggs, do the hot and cold check first. If the smell is on unsoftened taps too, or appeared suddenly across the house, call your utility. In North Port, that's North Port Utilities at 941-240-8000 (City of North Port).
FAQ
Why does my softened water smell like rotten eggs? If only softened water smells, Florida DOH says the likely cause is sulfur bacteria in the softener.
Is it the salt? We haven't seen an official source that blames softener salt itself. Brine tank problems and regeneration problems are worth checking, though. Follow the manufacturer's instructions.
Why does only my hot water smell? DOH says a hot-tap-only smell usually points to the water heater, not the softener.
Will replacing the softener fix the smell? Not if the source is the well, the plumbing or the groundwater. Do the four-way check first.
Can I bypass the softener while I sort it out? Most softeners have a bypass valve. Check your manual or ask your installer how to use it on your model.
Is sulfur-smelling water safe to drink? DOH says sulfur bacteria aren't harmful, but a smell can't tell you about bacteria like E. coli. Well owners should test.
Sources
Florida DOH: Well water facts, odor and staining (PDF)
City of North Port Utilities Department: contact number
Talk to Pure Harbor Water
Softener smelling like eggs? Call 941-294-5767, request a callback or schedule an in-home water check. We'll check the whole system, not just the softener.
A PRACTICAL NEXT STEP
Water softening, explained.
Reduce hardness minerals and the scale they can leave behind.
Explore this solution