THE SHORT ANSWER
If the rotten-egg smell comes only from the hot tap, the problem is most likely in the water heater, not your water supply, according to the Florida Department of Health (FL DOH fact sheet). The Minnesota Department of Health explains why: the heater's magnesium anode rod can help turn sulfate in the water into hydrogen sulfide gas, and the warm tank can host sulfur bacteria (MDH). The fixes (a different anode, disinfecting and flushing the heater, or a supervised high-temperature flush) are jobs for a plumber.
FAQ (quick)
- Is it dangerous to drink? FL DOH says sulfur bacteria aren't harmful, and the smell usually doesn't reflect how clean the water is. Well owners should still test for bacteria and nitrate.
- Why only hot water? Heat makes the gas vaporize, so the smell is often stronger at a hot tap (FL DOH). A heater can also make the gas itself (MDH).
- Will a whole-house filter fix it? Not if the heater is the source. Fix the heater first.
- I'm on city water. Does this apply? Both health departments write for well owners. On city water, a hot-only smell is still a reason to have the heater checked; report any cold-water odor to your utility.
- Do you fix water heaters? No. Call a licensed plumber or the heater's dealer.
Step 1: confirm it's hot-only
MDH's method: after you've been away from home for a few hours, smell the water from the hot and cold faucets and note which ones smell (MDH). Then compare with FL DOH's sorting guide (FL DOH):
| What you notice | Likely source (FL DOH) | Where to go |
|---|---|---|
| Smell only from the hot faucet | Water heater | Keep reading |
| Hot and cold, but only in softened water | Sulfur bacteria in the softener | Rotten-egg smell after a softener |
| Strong at first, fades as water runs, or varies | Sulfur bacteria in the well or plumbing | Hot vs. cold sulfur check |
| Strong and steady from hot and cold | Hydrogen sulfide in the groundwater | North Port sulfur water treatment |
If the cold water smells too, the heater isn't the whole story. Start with the hot vs. cold sulfur check.
Step 2: understand what's happening in the tank
MDH says a water heater can produce hydrogen sulfide in two ways (MDH):
- A warm home for sulfur bacteria. The tank's warm water lets them live and grow.
- A reaction with the anode. Heaters usually contain a metal rod called an anode, installed to reduce corrosion of the tank. It's usually magnesium, which can supply electrons that help convert sulfate in the water to hydrogen sulfide gas. MDH describes the rod as about 1/2 to 3/4 inch thick and 30 to 40 inches long.
FL DOH's fact sheet also lists chemical reactions inside water heaters among the sources of the gas.
Step 3: the fixes health agencies list (and who should do them)
MDH says that unless you're very familiar with water heater operation and maintenance, have a plumber or water system professional do the work. Its options (MDH):
| Option (MDH) | What MDH says | What to ask your plumber |
|---|---|---|
| Replace the magnesium anode | Ask a water heater dealer whether an anode of a different material, such as aluminum, can be installed; it may protect against corrosion without adding to the gas | Which replacement anode does the heater's maker approve? |
| Remove the anode | Possible, but removal "may significantly decrease the life of the water heater" | Is that worth it for this heater, or is replacement the better choice? |
| Disinfect and flush with chlorine bleach | Chlorination can kill sulfur bacteria; if not all are destroyed, the smell may return within a few weeks | How will you flush it, and what if the smell comes back? |
| Raise the heater to 160°F (71°C) for several hours, then flush | Destroys sulfur bacteria. MDH's caution: this can be dangerous; check with the manufacturer or dealer about a working pressure relief valve, and turn the thermostat back down afterward to prevent scalding and high energy costs | Is the relief valve working, and who resets the thermostat? |
We don't publish bleach amounts or do-it-yourself steps here. The live checklist on our site makes the same call: leave heater inspection, anode decisions and disinfection to a qualified professional.
Step 4: if it comes back, look upstream
If the smell returns after the heater is treated, or spreads to the cold side, the source may be the well, the plumbing or a softener:
- On a private well: MDH says the smell usually doesn't relate to the sanitary quality of the water but, to be safe, test for coliform bacteria and nitrate. FL DOH recommends testing at least once a year and whenever taste, odor or color changes. See well water treatment in North Port, Port Charlotte well water and private well lab sample planning.
- With a softener: see rotten-egg smell after a softener.
- Whole-house sulfur: FL DOH lists aeration, oxidation and activated carbon (adsorption) as treatment options for odor compounds. See North Port sulfur water treatment.
Safety note
MDH says hydrogen sulfide gas in the air can be harmful at high levels, and that only well professionals using proper safety precautions should enter a well pit or other enclosed space where the gas may be present (MDH). Don't go looking for the smell in a well pit or well house.
FAQ
Is it safe to shower in hot water that smells like rotten eggs? FL DOH says sulfur bacteria aren't harmful and the smell usually doesn't reflect how clean the water is. If you're on a well, test for total coliform or E. coli regularly to be sure (FL DOH). See is sulfur water safe to drink?
Will a water softener fix the smell? Not by itself. CDC describes softeners as removing minerals, mainly calcium and magnesium (CDC), and FL DOH notes a softener can itself host sulfur bacteria.
Why did the smell start after the house sat empty? MDH's test asks you to smell the water after you've been away for a few hours, so standing water is part of the picture. For homes left empty for weeks, see seasonal home water system handover.
Can I swap the anode rod myself? MDH recommends a plumber or water system professional unless you're very familiar with water heaters. Check your heater's manual and warranty before anyone changes the anode.
Do you install sulfur treatment? Yes, for smell that comes from the water supply (hot and cold), based on test results. For heater-only smell, call a plumber first.
Next step
Heater-only smell? Call a licensed plumber. Smell in the cold water too, or on a well? Schedule an in-home water check. It isn't a certified lab test; we use it to match treatment to your lab results and what you notice at each tap. Or call 941-294-5767. More: Iron bacteria in Florida wells · Well water treatment
Sources
Drafted 2026-11-12 (America/New_York); sources fetched the same day. Last fact-checked: 2026-11-12 (America/New_York).
- FL DOH, Well water facts: odor and staining
- Minnesota Department of Health, Why does my water smell like rotten eggs? Hydrogen sulfide and sulfur bacteria in well water
- Minnesota Department of Health, Hydrogen sulfide and sulfur bacteria in well water (brochure PDF)
- FL DOH, Private well water
- CDC, About Home Water Treatment Systems
A PRACTICAL NEXT STEP
Well-water planning, explained.
Build a treatment plan around your well, your concerns, and appropriate testing.
Explore this solution